When Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie premiered as a feature-length continuation of the cult Canadian web series and subsequent television revival, the question was whether its anarchic, DIY mockumentary energy could survive the jump to cinema. Now that major critics have weighed in, the verdict is emphatic: the film is one of the most acclaimed comedies of the year, even as a few reviewers caution that its manic style may test some viewers’ patience.
Directed by Matt Johnson and co-written with and starring Jay McCarrol, the R-rated comedy runs a brisk 1 hour and 40 minutes. The film sees fictionalised versions of the duo once again obsessively attempting to book a gig at Toronto’s Rivoli — despite having no songs, no recordings, and no contact with management. When their latest scheme goes disastrously wrong, Matt and Jay accidentally travel back to 2008, launching a chaotic time-travel spiral that expands the show’s mythology while doubling down on its delusional charm.
Critically, the response has been overwhelming. The film is Certified Fresh at 97% on Rotten Tomatoes, with an equally impressive 96% audience score — a rare alignment between critics and moviegoers for a comedy this niche and self-referential.
RogerEbert.com described the film as “an early contender for the funniest and most charming movie of the year,” praising its escalating absurdity and emotional undercurrents beneath the chaos. The review emphasizes that while the film is packed with meta-humor and self-aware insanity, it remains grounded in the friendship dynamic between its leads.
The Hollywood Reporter offered a more measured perspective, referring to the film as a “patience-testing Canadian mockumentary.” While acknowledging its ambition and comedic audacity, the outlet suggests that the film’s relentless energy and shaggy structure may not work equally for all audiences. Even so, it recognizes the film’s singularity within the comedy landscape.
Festival and trade coverage has also emphasized the film’s genre pivot. What began as a lo-fi music-industry satire evolves into an unexpectedly intricate time-travel narrative. Gold Derby encapsulated this surprise by calling it “the closest thing to a Back to the Future sequel we’re going to get,” underscoring the film’s playful engagement with sci-fi mechanics without sacrificing its absurdist tone.
Rotten Tomatoes’ critic consensus reinforces the broadly positive reception, stating: “Combining slyly skillful filmmaking with gut-busting laughs, Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie will be pure heaven for fans of the series while making happy converts of the uninitiated.” Individual critics aggregated on the platform go further, with one calling it “indisputably one of the funniest comedies of the decade thus far,” while another praised Johnson and McCarrol’s “weird mix of Jackass, Portlandia, and Letterkenny” as refreshingly undented by studio polish.
The Daily Beast framed the film as “a wildly eccentric comedy,” highlighting its spontaneous encounters, fast-paced DIY aesthetic, and celebration of friendship and delusion. The review positions the film less as conventional narrative cinema and more as a joyous act of cinematic chaos — one that weaponizes awkwardness and improvisation as comedic tools.
Canadian critics have been especially enthusiastic. Chris Knight of Original-Cin awarded the film an A rating, suggesting that longtime fans should “prepare to fall in love” all over again. For Canadian publications, the film’s specificity — its Toronto setting, Rivoli fixation, and deeply local humor — becomes part of its charm rather than a limitation.
One of the recurring themes across reviews is how seamlessly the film blends its mockumentary roots with ambitious genre escalation. Johnson’s previous work — including The Dirties, Operation Avalanche and BlackBerry — demonstrated a talent for blurring fact and fiction. Here, that instinct is pushed into sci-fi territory. The time-travel framework, rather than feeling like a gimmick, is widely seen as a clever narrative device that expands the stakes while preserving the duo’s delusional commitment to their band.
At the same time, reviewers acknowledge that the film’s chaotic structure is not conventional. The Hollywood Reporter’s “patience-testing” remark reflects a minority concern that the film’s shaggy, improvisational rhythm may exhaust viewers unfamiliar with the original series. A handful of critics suggest that some sequences run longer than necessary or lean heavily into inside-baseball humor. Yet even those reservations tend to coexist with admiration for the film’s sheer audacity.
Stylistically, critics emphasize the movie’s guerrilla filmmaking energy. Its blend of real-world interactions, staged absurdity, and time-loop mechanics gives it a texture that feels handmade and immediate. Rather than smoothing out its rough edges for theatrical polish, the film doubles down on its scrappy origins. That authenticity, many argue, is precisely what makes it work.
Commercially, the film is also making a solid impression for an indie comedy. Distributed by Neon, Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie is eyeing an estimated $1.25 million for the three-day weekend and a projected $1.4 million across the four-day frame, playing on 365 screens — a promising start for a cult expansion with highly specific humor.
In synthesizing the critical landscape, Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie emerges as one of the year’s most celebrated comedies. While not immune to criticism about pacing and tonal overload, the overwhelming response praises its originality, fearlessness, and comedic inventiveness. For many reviewers, it represents a rare feat: a cult property that not only survives the leap to feature length but expands its mythology in wildly entertaining fashion.
In an era of increasingly formulaic studio comedies, critics appear united in celebrating its refusal to conform. Whether experienced as a time-travel farce, a mockumentary meta-commentary, or simply a chaotic ode to delusional artistic ambition, the film has clearly struck a chord — with critics and audiences alike.
Read More Review Roundups on POF