Ryan Gosling has built a reputation for balancing blockbuster spectacle with emotional sincerity, and Project Hail Mary arrives as one of the most anticipated sci-fi releases of the year. Directed by Phil Lord and Christopher Miller and adapted from Andy Weir’s bestselling novel, the film follows a lone astronaut who wakes up on a distant spacecraft with no memory of how he got there — only to discover he may be humanity’s last hope of survival. Now that major publications have weighed in, Project Hail Mary reviews suggest the film is a crowd-pleasing sci-fi adventure powered by Ryan Gosling’s charm, inventive science, and an unexpectedly emotional alien friendship. Early ratings have been strong as well, with the film debuting around the mid-90% range on Rotten Tomatoes and generating enthusiastic early reactions across the industry.
Across reviews from major outlets, Gosling’s performance as astronaut Ryland Grace stands out as the film’s most universally praised element. Critics repeatedly highlight the actor’s ability to balance humor, vulnerability and scientific curiosity while anchoring a story that spends much of its runtime inside a spacecraft. IndieWire captured the tone succinctly, writing that “Ryan Gosling goes full ‘Martian,’ and thank the heavens for that,” positioning the performance as the emotional engine that keeps the film engaging even when the story becomes heavy on scientific explanation. Similarly, BBC noted that “Ryan Gosling’s charm carries this last-ditch space mission,” emphasizing how the actor’s comedic timing and natural likability help translate the novel’s dense scientific concepts into accessible entertainment. Empire echoed this sentiment, describing the movie as “an old-school sci-fi adventure that leans heavily on Gosling’s easy charisma,” suggesting the film thrives on the strength of its central performance.
Much of the film’s emotional impact, however, comes from the unexpected relationship between Grace and an alien companion named Rocky — a narrative turn that transforms the survival thriller into something closer to a cosmic friendship story. The Hollywood Reporter highlighted this dynamic in its headline observation that “Ryan Gosling proves he can have chemistry with a rock,” referring to the alien character whose bond with Grace forms the heart of the film. The review further noted that “warmth and humor keep the film grounded even as the science grows increasingly elaborate,” suggesting that the emotional connection between the characters prevents the story from becoming purely technical. Critics across outlets echoed that perspective, with The Verge describing the film as turning “first contact into an unlikely buddy comedy,” while RogerEbert.com called the movie “a big-hearted sci-fi adventure powered by curiosity and connection.” Together, these responses underline how the film’s tone blends spectacle with an optimistic emotional core.
Beyond the central performances, critics also praised the film’s balance of scientific detail and blockbuster entertainment. Adapted by screenwriter Drew Goddard, the film attempts to translate the complex physics and astrophysics concepts from Weir’s novel into cinematic spectacle without losing the story’s sense of humor. Screen Daily described the result as an irreverent blend of science fiction and comedy, writing that “Ryan Gosling is a wisecracking hero in Lord and Miller’s irreverent sci-fi.” The broader consensus among critics compiled by Rotten Tomatoes similarly describes the film as “an exciting, heartwarming, visually spectacular crowd-pleaser,” reinforcing the sense that the adaptation succeeds in translating the book’s appeal into a mainstream cinematic experience.
Still, the reception has not been entirely unanimous. Some critics argue that the film’s ambition occasionally results in pacing issues and an overreliance on exposition. Writing in Variety, critic Owen Gleiberman suggested the film’s ambition occasionally outpaces its narrative focus, remarking that it “wants to be Interstellar meets E.T., but it’s too long.” The comment reflects a broader criticism among some reviewers that the movie’s scientific explanations and extended runtime sometimes slow the momentum of the adventure. The Guardian offered a similarly mixed perspective, observing that “Ryan Gosling’s charm carries this unserious last-ditch space mission,” praising the actor’s performance while suggesting the story itself leans toward a lighter tone than traditional hard science fiction. Meanwhile, Esquire noted that “for all its adorable intentions, the alien-buddy movie sometimes struggles to land,” pointing to tonal inconsistencies between the film’s emotional ambitions and its comedic sensibilities.
Alongside the formal critic reviews, early social media reactions have also been enthusiastic, particularly among film commentators who attended advance screenings. Awards Radar editor Joey Magidson wrote that he “absolutely loved Project Hail Mary, the best film of 2026 so far,” praising the emotional bond between Grace and Rocky as the film’s standout element. Meanwhile, Sonny Bunch of The Bulwark described the movie as “alternately hilarious, heart-rending and thrilling… pretty close to perfect popcorn entertainment.” These early reactions echo the broader critical consensus that the film succeeds primarily as an entertaining and heartfelt science-fiction spectacle rather than a strictly cerebral one.
Taken together, the critical response to Project Hail Mary paints a picture of a film that blends ambitious science fiction with accessible humor and emotional warmth. While some reviewers feel the movie leans too heavily on exposition or runs longer than necessary, most agree that Gosling’s performance and the central interspecies friendship give the film a unique charm. In an era when large-scale science fiction often struggles to balance spectacle with heart, the film appears to have struck a tone that resonates with both critics and audiences — even if it occasionally reaches for more than it can fully contain.
Film Details
Film: Project Hail Mary
Directors: Phil Lord, Christopher Miller
Writer: Drew Goddard
Based on: The novel by Andy Weir
Cast: Ryan Gosling, Sandra Hüller, Milana Vayntrub
Runtime: 156 minutes
Rating: PG-13
Release Date: March 20, 2026
Read More Review Roundups on POF