Scary Movie 6 review roundup: After more than a decade away from theaters, the Scary Movie franchise is back. The sixth installment reunites franchise veterans Anna Faris, Regina Hall, Marlon Wayans, and Shawn Wayans for the first Scary Movie film since 2013, reviving a comedy series that once dominated pop-culture parody. For many fans, the return of the original creative voices behind the franchise was reason enough to celebrate. For critics, however, the reunion has generated a far more complicated response.
The broad consensus emerging from reviews is that Scary Movie 6 benefits enormously from the return of its original cast and creators, but struggles to justify its comeback with genuinely fresh comedy. Critics have largely welcomed the nostalgia, the surprise cameos, and the chemistry between familiar characters, yet many argue that the film relies too heavily on callbacks and outdated humor instead of finding new ways to satirize modern horror.
The new film brings back Cindy Campbell, Brenda Meeks, Ray Wilkins, and Shorty Meeks, now older and navigating a world that has changed considerably since audiences last saw them. At the center of the story is a new generation of teenagers who find themselves caught up in a Ghostface-style mystery inspired by the recent Scream films. Along the way, the movie parodies a wide range of modern horror titles, including Scream 5, Scream VI, Smile, Terrifier, The Substance, M3GAN, Get Out, Final Destination, and several other genre hits from the last decade.
The setup gives the filmmakers an enormous amount of material to work with. Modern horror has evolved dramatically since the franchise’s heyday, creating opportunities to satirize everything from elevated horror and prestige filmmaking to legacy sequels and fandom culture. Yet many critics argue that while the film identifies the right targets, it rarely finds the sharp comedic ideas necessary to make those targets memorable.
One area where critics are nearly unanimous is their appreciation for the returning cast. Anna Faris once again emerges as the film’s biggest asset, with many reviews praising her comic timing and ability to make even weaker material work. Regina Hall’s return as Brenda has also been widely celebrated, with critics noting that the chemistry between Faris and Hall remains one of the franchise’s greatest strengths. Several reviews suggest that whenever the film focuses on Cindy and Brenda, it briefly recaptures some of the chaotic energy that made the original films so popular.
The returning ensemble generates considerable goodwill throughout the film. Longtime fans will likely enjoy seeing familiar faces return, and several critics acknowledged that simply watching these characters share the screen again creates moments of genuine affection. The reunion aspect of the movie is arguably its most successful component, providing a reminder of why the original films resonated with audiences in the first place.
Yet that nostalgia also becomes the film’s biggest obstacle. A recurring criticism across reviews is that Scary Movie 6 often mistakes nostalgia for comedy. Rather than using the return of beloved characters as a foundation for fresh jokes, critics argue that the film frequently leans on recognition alone. Familiar characters, recurring gags, and references to earlier installments generate occasional smiles, but many reviewers felt the movie becomes overly dependent on reminding audiences of what they once loved instead of giving them something new to laugh at.
This observation aligns closely with one of the strongest points raised in our contributor review, which argued that the film spends too much time looking backward. Several major critics reached a similar conclusion, suggesting that the movie often behaves as though the mere return of the franchise should be enough to sustain audience enthusiasm. While nostalgia certainly creates goodwill, many reviewers felt it cannot carry an entire feature.
The film’s humor has emerged as the most divisive element of the critical conversation. While a handful of critics found enough laughs to recommend the movie, the majority argued that the comedy feels stuck in an earlier era. Reviews repeatedly describe the jokes as stale, repetitive, or overly reliant on broad shock humor. Critics noted that many punchlines feel as though they were written for a very different comedy landscape, one that no longer exists.
Several publications argued that the film struggles to evolve beyond the sensibilities that defined the franchise in the early 2000s. Instead of reinventing its comedic approach for modern audiences, Scary Movie 6 often returns to familiar formulas. Some reviewers felt the movie confuses references with jokes, assuming that merely mentioning a popular horror film is enough to generate laughter. Others criticized the screenplay for recycling old comic rhythms without finding fresh angles.
The parody of modern horror has become another major talking point. On paper, the film has access to some of the richest material the franchise has ever had. Contemporary horror has produced a fascinating mix of elevated psychological thrillers, legacy sequels, viral horror sensations, and socially conscious genre filmmaking. Critics generally agree that these films offer fertile ground for satire.
However, many reviews argue that Scary Movie 6 rarely digs beneath the surface. The references are plentiful, but the actual satire often feels shallow. Rather than examining what makes films like Get Out, The Substance, Smile, or Terrifier culturally significant, the movie frequently settles for visual callbacks and recognition-based humor. Critics from several publications described the satire as toothless, arguing that the film identifies modern horror trends without having much to say about them.
This criticism is particularly significant because the original Scary Movie films were often at their best when they aggressively mocked contemporary pop culture. The first entries in the franchise did more than simply reference popular movies; they exaggerated, distorted, and ridiculed them. Many critics believe the new film lacks that same satirical edge, resulting in a parody that feels surprisingly safe.
That isn’t to say the film is entirely devoid of laughs. Several reviews highlighted individual sequences, surprise cameos, and supporting characters as bright spots. One recurring point of praise involves the return of Doofy, whose appearance generated some of the strongest audience reactions. Critics who otherwise disliked the film frequently acknowledged that certain cameos and callbacks still work, particularly for longtime fans invested in the franchise’s history.
The pre-credits material, surprise appearances, and occasional self-aware jokes have also received positive mentions. Even some of the harsher reviews admit that the film contains isolated moments that capture the absurd spirit of the original series. The problem, according to most critics, is consistency. The successful jokes are simply too scattered throughout a movie that struggles to maintain momentum.
Interestingly, many reviews spend as much time discussing the original Scary Movie films as they do the new one. Critics repeatedly compare the sixth installment to its predecessors, often concluding that the earlier films felt sharper, riskier, and more culturally engaged. The original entries thrived because they arrived at a moment when parody cinema felt rebellious and unpredictable. They aggressively targeted contemporary trends and frequently pushed comedy to outrageous extremes.
By contrast, many critics argue that Scary Movie 6 feels overly comfortable. Rather than challenging modern horror or finding new satirical angles, the film often relies on audience familiarity with existing franchises. The result is a movie that references horror culture more than it actually critiques it.
This ultimately leads to the central consensus surrounding the film. Critics seem to respect the reunion more than the movie itself. There is genuine appreciation for the return of Anna Faris, Regina Hall, Marlon Wayans, and Shawn Wayans. There is enthusiasm for the idea of reviving parody cinema. There is even admiration for individual jokes, cameos, and performances. But many reviewers argue that these strengths are not enough to overcome a screenplay that struggles to evolve with its audience.
In some ways, the reaction to Scary Movie 6 says as much about the current state of comedy as it does about the film itself. The parody genre has largely disappeared from mainstream theaters, creating understandable excitement around the franchise’s return. What’s particularly interesting is that the comeback arrives at a time when horror itself is experiencing one of its strongest periods in years and Scary Movie is getting good Box Office traction as trade predictions suggest. With audiences embracing everything from prestige horror to viral internet-inspired phenomena, the raw material for sharp parody has never been richer. Yet critics largely argue that Scary Movie 6 fails to fully capitalize on that opportunity, relying on nostalgia more than incisive satire.
The overall critical consensus suggests that Scary Movie 6 succeeds as a nostalgic reunion but falls short as a modern reinvention. Anna Faris and Regina Hall remain immensely likable, a handful of jokes and cameos land successfully, and longtime fans may enjoy spending time with these characters again. Yet most critics agree that the film’s humor feels dated, its satire lacks bite, and its reliance on nostalgia ultimately prevents it from becoming the triumphant revival many hoped for.
The return of Scary Movie proves there is still an audience for horror parody. The challenge now is ensuring that the genre’s future is built on more than memories of its past.
Film: Scary Movie 6
Rating: R
Genre: Comedy, Horror, Parody
Director: Keenen Ivory Wayans
Cast: Anna Faris, Regina Hall, Marlon Wayans, Shawn Wayans, Dave Sheridan, Olivia Rose Keegan
Release Date: June 5, 2026
Read More Review Roundups on POF