Hershey Review Roundup: Critics Find Finn Wittrock’s Milton Hershey Biopic Bland and Overly Sweet

Finn Wittrock as Milton Hershey in Angel Studios’ biographical drama Hershey
November 18, 2026

Angel Studios’ Hershey, starring Finn Wittrock as chocolate company founder Milton S. Hershey, has received a largely negative response in the three reviews published so far, ahead of its US theatrical release. Directed by Mark Waters, the biographical drama also features Alexandra Daddario as Hershey’s wife, Kitty, alongside Alan Ruck, Richard Kind and David Costabile. While critics recognise the potential in the story of Hershey’s journey from repeated business failures to building a confectionery empire, they largely agree that predictable storytelling and an overly polished portrayal of its central figure prevent the film from achieving the emotional depth its subject demands.

The film follows Hershey from his childhood in rural Pennsylvania through his early training in candy-making, his attempts to establish successful businesses and his eventual move into chocolate production. His relationship with Kitty forms a significant part of the narrative, alongside their decision to establish a company town and support the education of orphaned children. Spanning several decades, the story presents professional setbacks and personal experiences as successive stages in the creation of the legacy associated with the Hershey name.

However, one of the most consistent criticisms concerns the screenplay’s straightforward approach to conflict. Alex Harrison of ScreenRant describes the film as an inoffensively bland biopic, arguing that a potentially inspiring real-life story is weakened by frictionless storytelling. Problems emerge and are resolved quickly, often through convenient developments that leave little room for tension or meaningful character progression. For Harrison, the film has the basic ingredients of an engaging biographical drama but does not create the dramatic momentum needed to make Hershey’s journey compelling.

Frank Scheck of The Hollywood Reporter raises similar concerns, describing the screenplay as episodic and predictable. In his assessment, fortunate developments repeatedly help Hershey overcome obstacles, making the progression towards success feel too easy. The film moves through major events in its protagonist’s life without giving enough weight to the difficulties and uncertainties that could have made those experiences more affecting. Scheck also finds Waters’ direction lacking the energy associated with some of his earlier films, including Mean Girls and Freaky Friday.

David Ehrlich of IndieWire delivers the harshest assessment, calling Hershey an unbelievably flavorless biopic and awarding it a D. He argues that the film turns the businessman’s life into a simplified march towards success, avoiding the complexity that might have made the character and his story feel more fully realised. Rather than exploring the contradictions and difficult decisions behind the public legacy, the film presents a largely uncomplicated account of achievement.

The treatment of Hershey’s legacy emerges as another major point of disagreement between the film’s celebratory approach and the critics’ expectations. Scheck notes that the narrative presents Hershey as a benevolent employer and philanthropist but leaves out later labour disputes and the history of racial exclusion at the school established by Hershey and his wife. These omissions become particularly significant in a biographical film that seeks to celebrate the achievements and legacy of a real business figure. By concentrating on the philanthropic aspects of his life without addressing more difficult parts of that legacy, the film offers a selective account of its subject.

Ehrlich raises similar concerns, arguing that the film avoids uncomfortable aspects of Hershey’s history. He also points to Hershey Entities’ involvement in the production, describing the project as an authorised, feature-length promotion of the brand. Scheck likewise considers the film overly sanitised, with its prominent product imagery reinforcing the impression that the production is closely tied to the commercial identity it portrays. For both critics, the film’s reluctance to complicate its central figure limits its value as a biographical account.

The performances receive a more varied response, although they do little to overcome the screenplay’s perceived limitations. Scheck feels that Wittrock makes a reasonable effort as Milton Hershey but cannot fully bring the character to life within the film’s predictable structure. Harrison also recognises the limitations of the material, even as the performances offer moments of warmth. The criticism is therefore directed less at the individual actors than at the writing and the way the story has been constructed around them.

Alexandra Daddario receives more consistent praise for her portrayal of Kitty Hershey. Scheck appreciates the warmth and playfulness she brings to the role, finding that her performance provides some of the film’s emotional appeal. Harrison also singles her out as a highlight, particularly for the way she gives Kitty a presence that helps soften the film’s otherwise conventional treatment of its subject. Richard Kind, who plays confectioner Joseph Royer, earns a positive mention from Scheck for his gentle screen presence.

The film’s period atmosphere also receives some acknowledgement. Harrison appreciates the recreation of the past and suggests that the material has the potential to become a heartwarming drama. However, that potential is not fully realised in the finished film. Scheck finds the presentation too polished and predictable to become genuinely engaging, while Ehrlich criticises its sentimental treatment of major events. The period setting and production design may provide an appealing backdrop, but they cannot compensate for the lack of dramatic tension identified across the reviews.

One sequence singled out by both Scheck and Ehrlich involves the Titanic. Milton and Kitty celebrate after learning that they have avoided travelling on the doomed ship. The moment becomes an example of what the critics consider the film’s tendency to frame major events through the lens of personal good fortune. Rather than using the historical context to introduce a more complex emotional or dramatic dimension, the sequence reinforces the film’s focus on the couple’s fortunate circumstances.

Taken together, the three reviews suggest that Hershey has a recognisable real-life success story, an appealing period setting and some performances that offer moments of warmth. However, its cautious screenplay, predictable progression and selective portrayal of its central figure prevent it from becoming the moving biographical drama its subject might have inspired. Daddario’s performance and the film’s historical atmosphere provide some positives, but the critical response indicates that the production struggles to move beyond a polished and sentimental account of Hershey’s life.

The central criticism emerging from these reviews is that Hershey approaches its subject with too much reverence and too little dramatic scrutiny. A story about business failures, the building of an industrial empire and a philanthropic legacy offers opportunities to explore ambition, personal relationships and the complexities of corporate history. Instead, critics find a narrative that moves too conveniently towards success while leaving difficult aspects of its subject’s legacy largely unexamined. The result, based on the three reviews available so far, is a biopic that appears more interested in celebrating the Hershey name than interrogating the life behind it.

Hershey is scheduled to release in US theatres on November 25, 2026, through Angel Studios.

Film Details: Hershey

  • Director: Mark Waters
  • Writers: Sharon Paul, Timothy Michael Hayes
  • Cast: Finn Wittrock, Alexandra Daddario, Alan Ruck, Richard Kind, David Costabile and others
  • Genre: Biographical Drama
  • Runtime: 110 minutes
  • Rating: PG
  • US Release Date: November 25, 2026

Share this post :

WhatsApp
Facebook
LinkedIn
Threads
X
Pinterest
Telegram
Email
Print

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

WEB STORIES